English is currently available.
Polymer Engineering DISCUSSION
An ABS enclosure has cantilever snap hooks 12 mm long and 2 mm thick at the root, with a 1.5 mm undercut. During assembly the hooks show stress whitening at the base and a few crack off, especially on the second or third time the cover is opened.
How do I calculate the strain in the hook during deflection, what strain is acceptable for ABS, and is it better to change the geometry or to move to a different material?
For a straight cantilever of constant rectangular section, the maximum strain at the root when the tip is deflected by y is ε = 1.5 × h × y / L², where h is the thickness at the root and L the length. With h = 2 mm, y = 1.5 mm and L = 12 mm: ε = 1.5 × 2 × 1.5 / 144 = 0.031, or 3.1 percent.
Material suppliers' snap-fit guides give permissible strains for a short-term deflection. For unfilled ABS the figures are around 2 percent for a single assembly, with a lower value, often about 60 percent of that, for joints that are opened repeatedly. Your hooks are above both limits, which matches the whitening and cracking.
Length is the most effective change because strain falls with the square of it. Keeping the same thickness and undercut, L = 20 mm gives ε = 1.5 × 2 × 1.5 / 400 = 1.1 percent, which is inside the repeated-use figure as well. If there is less room, reduce the thickness too: at h = 1.5 mm and L = 16 mm the strain is 1.5 × 1.5 × 1.5 / 256 = 1.3 percent.
Tapering the hook also helps. A beam whose thickness reduces to half at the tip spreads the strain along its length instead of concentrating it at the root, and permits roughly 60 percent more deflection for the same root strain. Where length is limited, a U-shaped or L-shaped hook, or slots in the wall beside the hook, add effective length.
Look at the root radius before anything else. A sharp internal corner where the hook meets the wall is a stress concentration, and the calculated 3 percent can be doubled locally. A fillet radius of about half the hook thickness is a common recommendation; going larger gives little extra benefit and creates a thick section that can sink.
Also check the mould: a weld line, a gate close to the hook root, or cold material filling a thin hook last will all weaken exactly the region that carries the peak strain. If cracked hooks always come from the same cavity or the same corner of the part, that is a moulding issue as well as a design one.
It is worth checking the assembly force as well, since a redesigned hook must still hold. The deflection force for a constant-section hook is P = b × h² × E × ε / (6 × L). For a hook 6 mm wide with h = 2 mm, L = 20 mm, E of about 2300 MPa for ABS and ε = 0.011: P = 6 × 4 × 2300 × 0.011 / (6 × 20) = about 5 N per hook. The push-in force is higher than this, depending on the lead-in angle and friction.
The retention depends on the angle of the return face: a 90 degree face locks permanently, while an angled face allows the cover to be pulled off.
On material: if the geometry cannot change, polycarbonate, PC/ABS blends and unfilled nylon tolerate more strain than ABS, and supplier guides quote permissible short-term strains around 4 percent for polycarbonate and higher still for conditioned nylon. Glass-filled grades go the other way, typically 1 to 2 percent, so a filled material needs longer, thinner hooks.
Whatever the material, design the joint so the hook is relaxed once assembled. A hook left deflected is under constant strain, and plastics under constant strain lose their clamping force through stress relaxation and can craze or crack over months, faster if oils, cleaners or other chemicals reach the stressed area.
